Sales
- 01236 700 270
- 01698 757 940
- info@kirklandestateagents.co.uk
Rentals
- 01236 802111
- enquiries@kirklandlettingagents.co.uk
Property valuation often feels like a blend of art and science—and for many property owners and buyers, it’s surrounded by confusing myths. With the property market in Scotland being distinct in a number of ways from the rest of the UK, misunderstanding the valuation process can lead to frustration or costly mistakes. Let’s tackle the most common myths and share what truly matters when valuing property in Scotland.
We completely understand the appeal of instant online valuations – they’re free, quick, and available 24/7. However, they’re best used as a starting point rather than a definitive answer.
Automated tools use historical sales data and basic property details, but they can’t see that your Victorian terrace has stunning original features, or that your flat overlooks a busy road rather than the park. They also struggle with Scotland’s diverse property types – a traditional stone cottage and a modern timber-frame house might both be three-bedroom properties, but their values could differ significantly.
The better approach: Use online tools to get a rough idea of your area’s price range, then speak to local professionals who can assess your specific property’s unique features, condition, and current market appeal.
Many people assume asking prices directly indicate market value, but in Scotland’s “offers over” system, they’re more like starting bids at an auction.
The reality is estate agents set asking prices to attract interest and potentially create competitive situations. A property advertised at “offers over £250,000” might realistically expect to achieve £265,000-£275,000, depending on interest levels and market conditions.
So if you’re buying, don’t dismiss properties based solely on asking prices – some may offer good value if interest is lower than expected. If you’re selling, understand that your agent’s pricing strategy aims to maximize final sale prices, not just match the asking figure.
This myth has led to many expensive disappointments. While some improvements definitely add value, others may not recoup their costs or might even put off certain buyers.
In Scotland’s climate, buyers particularly value energy efficiency improvements – better insulation, efficient heating systems, and high EPC ratings. Kitchen and bathroom updates usually add value, especially if they’re well-designed and suit the property’s character.
What’s less reliable – swimming pools, highly personalized decor, and over-improvement for the area don’t always pay back. A £30,000 kitchen in a modest terraced house might not add £30,000 to the sale price.
Focus on improvements that solve problems (leaky roofs, outdated electrics) or enhance everyday living (functional kitchens, comfortable heating). These tend to offer the best returns and appeal to more buyers.
While property has generally been a good long-term investment in Scotland, values don’t rise steadily every year. We’ve seen periods of decline, particularly during economic uncertainty, and some areas perform better than others.
The 2008 financial crisis saw values fall across Scotland, with recovery taking several years in some areas. More recently, Brexit uncertainty and the pandemic created market volatility that affected different regions differently.
Property is typically best viewed as a medium to long-term investment. If you need to sell within a few years, be prepared for the possibility that values might not have risen significantly, or could even be lower than when you bought.
Square footage matters, but it’s not everything. We’ve seen compact, well-designed homes outperform larger properties with poor layouts or significant maintenance issues.
Buyer value usable space, natural light, good proportions, and practical layouts often more than total floor area. A three-bedroom house where one bedroom is too small for a bed isn’t as valuable as a well-proportioned two-bedroom property.
In Scotland, features like high ceilings (common in Victorian properties), private outdoor space, and parking can add significant value regardless of indoor space. In cities like Glasgow and Edinburgh, even small gardens or guaranteed parking spaces command premiums.
We often meet sellers who remember what their neighbor’s house sold for five years ago, or buyers who think they’ve found a bargain because a property sold for more on a previous occasion. Unfortunately, old sale prices don’t set current values.
Property markets respond to current conditions – employment levels, interest rates, buyer demand, and local developments. A house that sold for £180,000 in 2019 might be worth £200,000 today in a strong market, or £170,000 if local conditions have changed.
Recent sales (ideally within the last 6-12 months) of similar properties in similar condition provide much more reliable value guidance than older transactions.
This view suggests agents routinely provide unrealistic valuations just to secure instructions. While this might occasionally happen, it’s generally bad business practice.
The reality is properties that are overvalued typically sit on the market longer, require price reductions, and often achieve lower final prices than realistic initial pricing would have secured. This benefits nobody and damages agent reputations. You can read our article on the problems with inaccurate valuations to understand how over (and under) valued properties can create problems for both the seller and agent.
How to spot a good practice: Professional agents should explain their valuation reasoning, provide comparable sales evidence, and discuss current market conditions honestly. Be wary of any valuation that seems too good to be true or lacks supporting evidence.
Some sellers feel frustrated when surveyor valuations come in lower than hoped, but there are good reasons for professional caution.
Surveyors must justify their valuations to rigorous standards and often value properties for mortgage purposes, where lenders need conservative estimates. They focus on what buyers have actually paid for similar properties rather than optimistic asking prices.
Surveyor valuations provide important reality checks, particularly in uncertain market conditions. If there’s a significant difference between a surveyor’s opinion and other estimates, it’s worth understanding why.
For Sellers:
For Buyers:
Understanding property valuations doesn’t have to be complicated. The key is getting reliable, current information from professionals who know your local market and can assess your specific circumstances.
Whether you’re buying or selling, realistic expectations based on current market evidence will serve you much better than outdated myths or wishful thinking. Every property and situation is different, which is why professional guidance tailored to your needs is so valuable.
Most importantly, remember that property transactions are significant financial decisions that deserve proper professional support. Don’t let common misconceptions cost you time, money, or opportunities in what should be an exciting process.
At Kirkland Estate Agents, we provide honest, professional property advice based on extensive local market knowledge. Serving Central Scotland, North Lanarkshire, South Lanarkshire, Glasgow, and surrounding areas, we’re here to help you navigate the Scottish property market with confidence. Contact us for a friendly chat about your property needs.
